The Idle City by Lord Dunsany

 


The Idle City - one of sixteen brief stories included in A Dreamer's Tales, a delightful collection of fantasy literature by Anglo-Irish author Lord Dunsany (1878-1957).

By my judgement, The Idle City is linked in special ways with two other tales from this collection - The Madness of Andelsprutz and Bethmoora. I'll offer comments on all three.

THE IDLE CITY
The custom of the city known as the Idle city is to demand all visitors tell a tale prior to being granted entrance. The narrator, one such visitor to the idle city, waits as three other visitors take their turn in telling their tale to the city guards. Following each tale - tales of profound events, of gods and angels, of mountains and dragons, of the cycle of life and death - the visitor is permitted to walk through the gates.

When it comes time for the narrator to tell his tale, the sun is setting and ghostly silences rise from distant hills. A stillness hangs over the city gates. And the great silence of the night is more acceptable to the guards at the gate then any sound of man. Therefore, the guards beckon the narrator to enter the city without the need for him to tell his tale.

Once in the idle city, the narrator reflects: "For how short a while man speaks, and withal how vainly. And for how long he is silent. Only the other day I met a king in Thebes, who had been silent already for four thousand years."

So few words but words rich in meaning. Even a great writer like Lord Dunsany recognizes our human speech, doesn't matter if the words are spoken as idle gossip on the street or as part of a classic performance on stage - Oedipus Rex, Hamlet, Romeo and Juliet - all human speech is but a speck in time, a brief moment in space, surrounded by an ocean, an infinity, an unending vista of silence.

THE MADNESS OF ANDELSPRUTZ
Hiking across fields and looking out at Andelsprutz, prior to remarking on the beauty of this singular city, the narrator shares observations on the vast differences one will encounter in cities, lyrical musings bringing to mind Italo Calvino and his Invisible Cities:

"There are cities full of happiness and cities full of pleasure, and cities full of gloom. There are cities with their faces to heaven, and some with their faces to earth; some have a way of looking at the past and others look at the future; some notice you if you come among them, others glance at you, others let you go by. Some love the cities that are their neighbours, others are dear to the plains and to the heath; some cities are bare to the wind, others have purple cloaks and others brown cloaks, and some are clad in white. Some tell the old tale of their infancy, with others it is secret; some cities sing and some mutter, some are angry, and some have broken hearts, and each city has her way of greeting Time."

Then the narrator fires off a batch of harsh zingers aimed at the city he's about to enter, concluding with this striking remark: "But the windows of Andelsprutz in her houses looked vacantly over the plains like the eyes of a dead madman." A city's windows likened to the eyes of a dead madman? What a powerful image!

And with nightfall, the narrator senses a much deeper gloom: "When the night fell and the blinds were all drawn down, then I perceived what I had not thought in the daylight. I knew then that Andelsprutz was dead."

Thus, he's prompted to seek an answer to his pressing question. He enters a cafe and proceeds to ask three different men why Andelsprutz is dead and her soul gone. The first and second man tell him a city does not posses a soul. They offer no further comment. But when the narrator comes upon a third man, a gent of slight build and black hair, he's provided a detailed account which includes the following haunting snip: "somewhere in the midst of a great desert are gathered together the souls of all dead cities."

Provocative, curious, bewitching - a tale that just might prompt you to think about the very city you are living in or near during these unsettling times.

BETHMOORA
Walking the streets of London, our narrator, a chap I'll call Drax, thinks of far distant Bethmoora, city of the desert sands, now completely empty, its inhabitants having fled years ago, or so he's been told.

Why? Legend has it on that fateful day when all the Bethmoorans gathered up their belongs and traveled either northwards or eastwards, three men on mules had been noticed crossing the face of the nearby Hills of Hap. And once those men on mules delivered their message at the copper gates of Bethmoora, delivered to dancers dressed in green and lilac who came out to meet them, the three strange travelers went back the way they came the instant their message was given. 

Many have speculated on the content of that message: some say Thuba Mleen, the ferocious emperor of those lands, advised all to leave immediately; some claim the message contained a warning from the gods, although no one knows if those gods were for or against the Bethmoorians; yet others think plague or another form of diabolical sickness. But most believe it was a message from the desert himself, spoken in a cry to those three travelers who could recognize his voice. 

Now, why would the desert want Bethmoora all to himself? In Drax's own words: "They say that the desert had a need for Bethmoora, that he wished to come into her lovely streets, and to send into her temples and her houses his storm-winds draped with sand. For he hates the sound and the sight of men in his old evil heart, and he would have Bethmoora silent and undisturbed, save for the weird love he whispers to her gates."

Again, all is speculation. Drax vows to one day leave London and travel south to uncover the mystery.

A Dreamer's Tales can be read online. Link: https://www.sacred-texts.com/neu/dun/...


Anglo-Irish author Edward John Moreton Drax Plunkett, 18th Baron of Dunsany, or, more commonly, the name he used for all his many books - Lord Dunsany

Comments